2.6 KiB
id, title, status, assignee, created_date, updated_date, labels, dependencies, priority, ordinal
| id | title | status | assignee | created_date | updated_date | labels | dependencies | priority | ordinal |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TASK-48 | Integrate impeccable critique into audit pipeline | In Progress | 2026-06-08 12:02 | 2026-06-08 12:10 | high | 50000 |
Description
Extend the evidence-first audit pipeline with design critique/impeccable-style visual and UX evaluation, especially the critique skill, while keeping verified findings evidence-linked and customer-safe.
Acceptance Criteria
- #1 Critique/impeccable skill guidance is inspected and translated into bounded audit stages or skill prompts
- #2 New critique findings stay evidence-linked and flow through the compact evidence verifier
- #3 German copy synthesis consumes only verified critique findings, not raw skill output
- #4 Audit UI exposes critique findings with evidence chips and actual skill purpose text
- #5 Focused and full regression tests cover the new critique integration
Implementation Plan
- Inspect impeccable/critique skill guidance and current audit pipeline shape
- Define a compact critique/impeccable stage that maps skill guidance into evidence-backed audit findings
- Add schemas/prompts or stage wiring without expanding verifier output size
- Update UI/tests so critique findings are visible with evidence and real skill purpose
- Run focused and full regression tests, deploy Convex dev, keep task In Progress for live confirmation
Implementation Notes
Implemented the impeccable/critique integration as an evidence-bound audit extension. Inspected the local impeccable and critique skills; no project-specific .impeccable.md was present, so the product guidance was translated into bounded audit behavior instead of broad design taste claims. Added the V3 skill registry entry impeccable-critique, prioritized it in selected local audit skills, and wired a new Convex critiqueSpecialist stage between visual trust and performance/accessibility. The stage is instructed to produce only evidence-linked findings using skillId impeccable-critique; the existing compact verifier and German synthesis path remain the gate, so raw specialist output is not customer-facing. UI tests continue to cover evidence chips and real registry purpose text. Verification: focused specialist/evidence tests 45/45 passed; skill/UI tests 15/15 passed; full pnpm test 388/388 passed; git diff --check passed; targeted ESLint passed; npx convex dev --once synced successfully.